Tired of limited loan options for your clients?

Go Broker. We’ve helped 100+ LOs make the switch successfully.

Your clients deserve more options. You deserve more income. Make both happen as an independent broker. Schedule a confidential call today.

Click HERE

* * * * *

FHA’s New Permanent Loan Sale Program: A Cause for Concern?

Recent developments at the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) have raised eyebrows across the mortgage industry. The agency has just published a final rule establishing a permanent program for selling seriously delinquent, FHA-insured single-family mortgages. While this might sound like standard regulatory procedure, a deeper look reveals potentially concerning implications for both the housing market and retirement investments.

Understanding the New Rule

The FHA’s latest rule modifies requirements for selling eligible single-family mortgage loans that have been assigned to the HUD Secretary in exchange for claim payments. The critical detail here? These mortgage notes are being sold without FHA insurance. This represents a significant shift in how the FHA handles troubled loans.

Why This Matters

Traditionally, when FHA-insured loans face problems with missed payments, the FHA would tap into their Mutual Mortgage Insurance (MMI) fund to cover losses. However, this new approach allows the FHA to unload troubled properties under favorable terms, potentially shifting the risk to investors’ retirement and investment portfolios – including 401(k)s and IRAs – without the safety net of FHA insurance.

Echoes of 2008

The parallels to the 2008 financial crisis are hard to ignore. During that period, subprime loans were packaged and sold to investors, leading to catastrophic consequences. While the FHA has apparently learned from that crisis, they may have learned a different lesson than intended – finding a way to avoid paying claims rather than preventing risky lending.

FHA’s Official Statement

The FHA’s own words are telling. They state that these mortgage notes are sold “without FHA insurance, to qualified purchasers in a manner that seeks to maximize recoveries and strengthen HUD’s Mutual Mortgage Insurance Fund (MMIF).” This might sound reasonable, but it raises questions considering the MMI fund currently holds five times the congressionally mandated amount – more than ever before.

Risk Metrics Tell a Concerning Story

Current data shows FHA loans consistently ranking as the riskiest across multiple metrics:

• Loan Performance: FHA loans perform below even non-QM loans
• Debt-to-Income Ratio: FHA leads with the highest DTI
• Loan-to-Value Ratio: Again, FHA tops the charts

Reading Between the Lines

These actions by the FHA raise several critical questions:

1. Does the FHA anticipate a significant downturn in their portfolio?
2. Is this a strategic move to shift insurance responsibility to investors?
3. What does this signal about the agency’s market outlook?

Implications for Industry Professionals

For loan officers and realtors, the message is clear: when a federal agency like HUD takes protective measures of this magnitude, it warrants attention. If FHA loans face significant troubles, the ripple effects could impact the entire industry.

The Bottom Line

While the FHA frames this as a program to strengthen their insurance fund, the timing and structure of this initiative suggest deeper concerns about market conditions. For industry professionals and investors alike, this development merits close attention and potentially defensive positioning in anticipation of market changes.

The real question remains: Is this a prudent regulatory adjustment, or is the FHA preparing for a storm that they see brewing on the horizon?