Zillow’s Shadow: Examining the Curious Case of Real Estate Litigation

A Partnership Serving Your Investor Clients

Introduce investors and let Truly take care of the rest.

Broker or referral partner, either way, you get paid!

Click HERE to sign-up and start your partnership today.

Hey Agents (or anyone else)…Licensing is not required for referral partners,

* * * * *

Zillow’s Shadow: Examining the Curious Case of Real Estate Litigation

The real estate industry is currently facing a storm of legal challenges from multiple fronts. Let’s break down the recent developments and their potential implications for the future of real estate transactions.

1. Buyer Commission Lawsuits on Hold

Judge LaShonda Hunt of the Northern District of Illinois has recently paused buyer class action lawsuits against three major companies pending seller appeals. Despite admitting a lack of familiarity with the issues and histories, Judge Hunt has taken over these cases, which involve recent home-buyers making claims similar to seller-filed lawsuits like Burnett, but with a different legal foundation.

Judge Hunt expressed her intention to observe the progression of the cases before determining necessary changes, stating, “I think it just makes sense to see how the case is progressing and then figure out what changes.” Her initial confusion about whether the plaintiffs were sellers or buyers highlights the complexity of these cases.

2. EXP Settles Georgia Lawsuit

In a separate development, EXP has settled a lawsuit in Georgia for $34 million. While denying any material allegations, the company has agreed to pay half of the settlement within 30 business days of preliminary court approval, with the remainder due within one year.

3. Shifting Stance on Broker-to-Broker Compensation

EXP CEO Leo Pareja recently suggested a significant change in approach to broker-to-broker compensation. He proposed that if such compensation was no longer allowed on the MLS, they might cease the practice entirely. This doesn’t preclude sellers from compensating buyer agents, but EXP would no longer facilitate this exchange. Pareja emphasized, “We’re just saying we want the seller to have a seat at the table and to be part of the decision-making process.”

4. Realtors Challenging NAR Membership Requirement

In Michigan, agents are suing the National Association of Realtors (NAR), claiming that the requirement for NAR membership to access the MLS violates federal law. They argue this mandate is “akin to mandating membership in a union or other trade organization, depriving members of free choice.”

5. The Zillow Question

Amid these legal battles, a glaring question emerges: Where does Zillow stand in all of this? As a company that leverages MLS data to generate billions, why aren’t they facing similar lawsuits? This absence raises important questions about the dynamics at play within the industry.

6. Historical Parallels and Industry Implications

Drawing parallels to other industries, it’s worth noting that companies like Facebook and YouTube have previously lobbied for lawsuits against themselves. While these lawsuits resulted in significant penalties, they also served to eliminate competition. Could a similar strategy be at play in the real estate industry?

7. Potential Consequences for Realtors

For individual realtors, these developments present a challenging landscape. Those who choose to disassociate from larger organizations or work with smaller, unaffiliated brokerages may find themselves insulated from these legal challenges. However, the industry as a whole faces uncertain times ahead.

Conclusion

As these legal battles unfold, they raise critical questions about the future of real estate transactions, the role of large brokerages, and the sustainability of current business models. The industry appears to be at a crossroads, with potential for significant changes in how real estate business is conducted in the coming years.